I never had anything against logical uncertainty :)
The point, though, is that this setup—where I can verify Omega’s honest attempt at randomness—does not produce the paradoxes. In particular, it does not allow someone to pump money out of me. And so it seems to me that I can and should “keep paying up in Counterfactual Mugging even when the logical coinflip looks as obvious as 2+2=4.”
I never had anything against logical uncertainty :)
The point, though, is that this setup—where I can verify Omega’s honest attempt at randomness—does not produce the paradoxes. In particular, it does not allow someone to pump money out of me. And so it seems to me that I can and should “keep paying up in Counterfactual Mugging even when the logical coinflip looks as obvious as 2+2=4.”