(a) They also laughed at Bozo the Clown. (I think this is Carl Sagan’s quote).
(b) Outside view: how often do outsiders solve a problem in a novel way, vs just adding noise and cluelessness to the discussion? Base rates! Again, nothing that I am saying is controversial, having good priors is a part of “rationality folklore” already. Going with expert consensus as a prior is a part of “rationality folklore” already. It’s just that people selectively follow rationality practices only when they are fun to follow.
(c) “In computer science, industry is often “ahead” of academia in the sense that important algorithms get discovered in industry first”
Yes, this sometimes happens. But again, base rates. Google/Facebook is full of academia-trained PhDs and ex-professors, so the line here is unclear. It’s not amateurs coming up with these algorithms. John Tukey came up with the Fast Fourier Transform while at Bell Labs, but he was John Tukey, and had a math PhD from Princeton.
(a) They also laughed at Bozo the Clown. (I think this is Carl Sagan’s quote).
(b) Outside view: how often do outsiders solve a problem in a novel way, vs just adding noise and cluelessness to the discussion? Base rates! Again, nothing that I am saying is controversial, having good priors is a part of “rationality folklore” already. Going with expert consensus as a prior is a part of “rationality folklore” already. It’s just that people selectively follow rationality practices only when they are fun to follow.
(c) “In computer science, industry is often “ahead” of academia in the sense that important algorithms get discovered in industry first”
Yes, this sometimes happens. But again, base rates. Google/Facebook is full of academia-trained PhDs and ex-professors, so the line here is unclear. It’s not amateurs coming up with these algorithms. John Tukey came up with the Fast Fourier Transform while at Bell Labs, but he was John Tukey, and had a math PhD from Princeton.