My instinct is to agree with this. I spent decades learning the intricacies of North-European politeness and I think I’ve finally more or less got it. Now that I’ve learned it, I might be motivated to think that there is some actual point to all this dancing around!
I like Stefan’s idea of connecting guess/ask with wait/interrupt. We might also want to bring the guilt/shame axis into this.
It sounds like ask/interrupt/shame should make for a more honest and efficient society. The guess/wait/guilt stuff sounds pretty frakked up when it is described. But in practice it seems to be correlated with the best places to live in. Maybe this is one of those Chesterton’s fence things:
If you don’t see the use of it, I certainly won’t let you clear it away. Go away and think. Then, when you can come back and tell me that you do see the use of it, I may allow you to destroy it.
Guessing is costly, and occurs more in cultures which are prosperous rather than desperate. There’s more than one way that sort of causal relationship can go.
My instinct is to agree with this. I spent decades learning the intricacies of North-European politeness and I think I’ve finally more or less got it. Now that I’ve learned it, I might be motivated to think that there is some actual point to all this dancing around!
I like Stefan’s idea of connecting guess/ask with wait/interrupt. We might also want to bring the guilt/shame axis into this.
It sounds like ask/interrupt/shame should make for a more honest and efficient society. The guess/wait/guilt stuff sounds pretty frakked up when it is described. But in practice it seems to be correlated with the best places to live in. Maybe this is one of those Chesterton’s fence things:
Or for a more recent version, xkcd on drama.
Guessing is costly, and occurs more in cultures which are prosperous rather than desperate. There’s more than one way that sort of causal relationship can go.