Ben, that’s not about additivism, but indicates that you are a deontologist by nature, as everyone is. A better test: would you flip a lever which would stop the torture if everyone on earth would instantly be automatically punched in the face? I don’t think I would.
I’m fairly certain I would pull the lever. And I’m certain that if I had to watch the person be tortured (or do it myself!) I would happily pull the lever.
It was this sort of intuition that motivated my earlier question to Eliezer (which he still hasn’t responded to). I’d be interested to hear from any of the people advocating torture over specks, though: would you all be willing to personally commit the torture, knowing that the alternative is either (a) a punch in the face (without permanent injury/pain/risk of death) to every human on the planet, or (b) in a universe with 3^^^3 people in it, a speck in everyone’s eye?
I suspect that the most people would refuse to pick up the blowtorch in either case. Which is very important—only some very exotic, and very implausible, metaethical theories would casually disregard the ethical intuitions of the vast majority of people.
Ben, that’s not about additivism, but indicates that you are a deontologist by nature, as everyone is. A better test: would you flip a lever which would stop the torture if everyone on earth would instantly be automatically punched in the face? I don’t think I would.
I’m fairly certain I would pull the lever. And I’m certain that if I had to watch the person be tortured (or do it myself!) I would happily pull the lever.
It was this sort of intuition that motivated my earlier question to Eliezer (which he still hasn’t responded to). I’d be interested to hear from any of the people advocating torture over specks, though: would you all be willing to personally commit the torture, knowing that the alternative is either (a) a punch in the face (without permanent injury/pain/risk of death) to every human on the planet, or (b) in a universe with 3^^^3 people in it, a speck in everyone’s eye?
I suspect that the most people would refuse to pick up the blowtorch in either case. Which is very important—only some very exotic, and very implausible, metaethical theories would casually disregard the ethical intuitions of the vast majority of people.