If it is meant as an attack on Paul, then it feels pretty bad/norm-violating to me. I don’t know what general principle I endorse that makes it not okay: maybe something like “don’t attack people in a really public and flashy way unless they’re super high-profile or hold an important public office”? If you’d like I can poke at the feeling more. Seems like some people in the Twitter thread (Alex Lawsen, Neel Nanda) share the feeling.
If I’m wrong and it’s not an attack, I still think they should have gotten Paul’s consent, and I think the fact that it might be interpreted as an attack (by people seeing the truck) is also relevant.
(Obviously, I think the events “this is at least partially an attack on Paul” and “at least one of the authors of this post are connected to Control AI” are positively correlated, since this post is an attack on Paul. My probabilities are roughly 85% and 97%*, respectively.)
*For a broad-ish definition of “connected to”
I don’t particularly see a reason to dox the people behind the truck, though I am not totally sure. My bar against doxxing is pretty high, though I do care about people being held accountable for large scale actions they take.
That’s fair. I think that it would be better for the world if Control AI were not anonymous, and I judge the group negatively for being anonymous. On the other hand, I don’t think I endorse them being doxxed. So perhaps my request to Connor and Gabriel is: please share what connection you have to Control AI, if any, and share what more information you have permission to share.
To elaborate on my feelings about the truck:
If it is meant as an attack on Paul, then it feels pretty bad/norm-violating to me. I don’t know what general principle I endorse that makes it not okay: maybe something like “don’t attack people in a really public and flashy way unless they’re super high-profile or hold an important public office”? If you’d like I can poke at the feeling more. Seems like some people in the Twitter thread (Alex Lawsen, Neel Nanda) share the feeling.
If I’m wrong and it’s not an attack, I still think they should have gotten Paul’s consent, and I think the fact that it might be interpreted as an attack (by people seeing the truck) is also relevant.
(Obviously, I think the events “this is at least partially an attack on Paul” and “at least one of the authors of this post are connected to Control AI” are positively correlated, since this post is an attack on Paul. My probabilities are roughly 85% and 97%*, respectively.)
*For a broad-ish definition of “connected to”
That’s fair. I think that it would be better for the world if Control AI were not anonymous, and I judge the group negatively for being anonymous. On the other hand, I don’t think I endorse them being doxxed. So perhaps my request to Connor and Gabriel is: please share what connection you have to Control AI, if any, and share what more information you have permission to share.