Maybe more description of the scenario would help. Presumably there’s no infinity here—there’s a bound to the disutility (for you; presumably it’s utility for me) I can get with my fraction of the cosmos. What do you think the proper reaction of an FAI (or a human, for that matter) is, and why is it different for repeated small events than for one large event?
OK. Why would this imply extortion rather than simple poverty?
Because you’re the one creating the multiple instances of disutility, using a fraction of the resources of the cosmos.
Maybe more description of the scenario would help. Presumably there’s no infinity here—there’s a bound to the disutility (for you; presumably it’s utility for me) I can get with my fraction of the cosmos. What do you think the proper reaction of an FAI (or a human, for that matter) is, and why is it different for repeated small events than for one large event?