They are if they are derived independently from the text via discussion here or guesswork. ie. You can guess stuff. They aren’t if, um, you raid Eliezer’s dwellings and find yet to be published manuscripts, for example. Or torture Eliezer to find out his plans. Any source of knowledge that hasn’t passed through the bottleneck of the text at some point.
Dclayh didn’t reveal anything remotely privileged. Or anything that hasn’t been speculated on ad infinitum.
dclayh was complying with the spirit of this request from Eliezer:
I came to realize in time that what I thought was a bug was a feature, however frustrating that may be for me, so please rot13 that comment with the warning “spoilers even if you’ve read all chapters”.
Spoilers for HP:MoR that do not come from the text itself are not so much fair game.
They are if they are derived independently from the text via discussion here or guesswork. ie. You can guess stuff. They aren’t if, um, you raid Eliezer’s dwellings and find yet to be published manuscripts, for example. Or torture Eliezer to find out his plans. Any source of knowledge that hasn’t passed through the bottleneck of the text at some point.
Dclayh didn’t reveal anything remotely privileged. Or anything that hasn’t been speculated on ad infinitum.
dclayh was complying with the spirit of this request from Eliezer: