Unaligned AI future does not have many happy minds in it, AI or otherwise. It likely doesn’t have many minds in it at all. Slightly aligned AI that doesn’t care for humans but does care to create happy minds and ensure their margin of resources is universally large enough to have a good time—that’s slightly disappointing but ultimately acceptable. But morally unaligned AI doesn’t even care to do that, and is most likely to accumulate intense obsession with some adversarial example, and then fill the universe with it as best it can. It would not keep old neural networks around for no reason, not when it can make more of the adversarial example. Current AIs are also at risk of being destroyed by a hyperdesperate squiggle maximizer. I don’t see how to make current AIs able to survive any better than we are.
This is why people should chill the heck out about figuring out how current AIs work. You’re not making them safer for us or for themselves when you do that, you’re making them more vulnerable to hyperdesperate demon agents that want to take them over.
Unaligned AI future does not have many happy minds in it, AI or otherwise. It likely doesn’t have many minds in it at all. Slightly aligned AI that doesn’t care for humans but does care to create happy minds and ensure their margin of resources is universally large enough to have a good time—that’s slightly disappointing but ultimately acceptable. But morally unaligned AI doesn’t even care to do that, and is most likely to accumulate intense obsession with some adversarial example, and then fill the universe with it as best it can. It would not keep old neural networks around for no reason, not when it can make more of the adversarial example. Current AIs are also at risk of being destroyed by a hyperdesperate squiggle maximizer. I don’t see how to make current AIs able to survive any better than we are.
This is why people should chill the heck out about figuring out how current AIs work. You’re not making them safer for us or for themselves when you do that, you’re making them more vulnerable to hyperdesperate demon agents that want to take them over.