The claims? No. The truth of those claims, their intended implications, whatever motte-and-baileying there may be around them, and so on — the things that actually matter, that is? Look and decide. There’s outside view, and there’s refusal to look at the inside.
If you automatically assume
That is an accusation of bad faith. I have not read the book but I have read the article and have said what I see.
The claims? No. The truth of those claims, their intended implications, whatever motte-and-baileying there may be around them, and so on — the things that actually matter, that is? Look and decide. There’s outside view, and there’s refusal to look at the inside.
That is an accusation of bad faith. I have not read the book but I have read the article and have said what I see.