The problem isn’t that people might pretend to like noise. Their liking of noise is irrelevant. The problem is that
a) Annoying people is a path to wealth, and
b) Even paying them off doesn’t make the problem go away, but draws in more people to try the same trick.
The motorcycle revver could actually hate noise, but simply love extortion payments drawn from the wealth that society has—or at least, has until people like him become too common and too tolerated.
It’s all about incentives. Rewarding people for threatening to do, but refraining from, some action, will lead to people capable of threatening convincingly making a great deal of wealth, up to some equilibrium point where either the action is sufficiently tolerated by society or the people who don’t like the action have become sufficiently poor that the public threats to do it are no longer rewarding enough.
The problem isn’t that people might pretend to like noise. Their liking of noise is irrelevant. The problem is that
a) Annoying people is a path to wealth, and b) Even paying them off doesn’t make the problem go away, but draws in more people to try the same trick.
The motorcycle revver could actually hate noise, but simply love extortion payments drawn from the wealth that society has—or at least, has until people like him become too common and too tolerated.
It’s all about incentives. Rewarding people for threatening to do, but refraining from, some action, will lead to people capable of threatening convincingly making a great deal of wealth, up to some equilibrium point where either the action is sufficiently tolerated by society or the people who don’t like the action have become sufficiently poor that the public threats to do it are no longer rewarding enough.
Yes, exactly right, but … did you mean that as a reply to RobinHanson?
Er, perhaps. I was generalizing a bit from what you said, so I wanted the context of your post. It was more directed at uninvolved readers, I think.
But I haven’t had much coffee yet today so I’m not sure.
Oh, okay. That works too. You have enough coffee; I’m just too combative today ;-)