Is the data easily available anywhere? If it’s not, that might explain why no one redid the analysis. If it is, I might be persuaded to try a few different models out.
EDIT: After some digging, I’m pretty sure I know what statistical model they used in the study and should be able to reproduce their results and try a few different things IF I can get the data in a sufficiently nice form.
EDIT2: see my recent post in the discussion section
I didn’t think I understood enough of what they did to comment usefully anymore, and I don’t have the time currently (i.e., this week) to put into understanding it. Did you read it after I had put the edit at the end? If so, did you still find it useful?
Is the data easily available anywhere? If it’s not, that might explain why no one redid the analysis. If it is, I might be persuaded to try a few different models out.
EDIT: After some digging, I’m pretty sure I know what statistical model they used in the study and should be able to reproduce their results and try a few different things IF I can get the data in a sufficiently nice form.
EDIT2: see my recent post in the discussion section
Why’d you delete it? :-( I was wondering earlier where it went.
I didn’t think I understood enough of what they did to comment usefully anymore, and I don’t have the time currently (i.e., this week) to put into understanding it. Did you read it after I had put the edit at the end? If so, did you still find it useful?