Circuit breaking changes the exponent a bit if you compare it to the slope of Llama3 (Figure 3 of the paper). So, there is some evidence that circuit breaking does more than just shifting the intercept when exposed to best-of-N attacks. This contrasts with the adversarial training on attacks in the MSJ paper, which doesn’t change the slope (we might see something similar if we do adversarial training with BoN attacks). Also, I expect that using input-output classifiers will change the slope significantly. Understanding how these slopes change with different defenses is the work we plan to do next!
Circuit breaking changes the exponent a bit if you compare it to the slope of Llama3 (Figure 3 of the paper). So, there is some evidence that circuit breaking does more than just shifting the intercept when exposed to best-of-N attacks. This contrasts with the adversarial training on attacks in the MSJ paper, which doesn’t change the slope (we might see something similar if we do adversarial training with BoN attacks). Also, I expect that using input-output classifiers will change the slope significantly. Understanding how these slopes change with different defenses is the work we plan to do next!