I weak-downvoted this: in general I think it is informative for people to just state their opinion, but in this case the opinion had very little to do with the content of the post and was not argued for. The linked post also did not engage with any of the existing arguments around TAI risk.
(Not that I disagree with “limiting the spread of autonomous weapons is going to lead to fewer human deaths in expectation”, but I don’t think it is the best strategy to limit such kinds of impact.)
Which part of my statement does not make sense, and how so?
My statement is relevent to the post. The beginning of the article partially defined hard alignment as preventing AI from destroying everything of value to us. The most likely way a rogue AI would do that is by gaining unauthorized access to weapons with built-in intelligence.
I dont think the most likely way is gaining access to autonomous weapons designed to kill. An ai smarter than all humans has many different options to take over, including making its own autonomous weapons
I weak-downvoted this: in general I think it is informative for people to just state their opinion, but in this case the opinion had very little to do with the content of the post and was not argued for. The linked post also did not engage with any of the existing arguments around TAI risk.
(Not that I disagree with “limiting the spread of autonomous weapons is going to lead to fewer human deaths in expectation”, but I don’t think it is the best strategy to limit such kinds of impact.)
Which part of my statement does not make sense, and how so?
My statement is relevent to the post. The beginning of the article partially defined hard alignment as preventing AI from destroying everything of value to us. The most likely way a rogue AI would do that is by gaining unauthorized access to weapons with built-in intelligence.
I dont think the most likely way is gaining access to autonomous weapons designed to kill. An ai smarter than all humans has many different options to take over, including making its own autonomous weapons