Either his tactics work perfectly and are guaranteed to win against you, or they are so worthless he shouldn’t mind opening the kimono and revealing everything to the world? A rather extreme premise under which to offer a game.
That doesn’t seem like a reply to my observation about your dichotomy. Please justify your offer first: why should the value of Tuxedage’s tactics be either extremely high or zero based on a single game, and not any intermediate value?
That seems like the clearest interpretation of your proposal, nor did you explain what you actually meant when I summarized it and called it a false dichotomy, nor have you explained what you actually meant in this comment either.
Why?
Either his tactics work perfectly and are guaranteed to win against you, or they are so worthless he shouldn’t mind opening the kimono and revealing everything to the world? A rather extreme premise under which to offer a game.
So what’s the point of keeping the logs secret if the GK wins?
That doesn’t seem like a reply to my observation about your dichotomy. Please justify your offer first: why should the value of Tuxedage’s tactics be either extremely high or zero based on a single game, and not any intermediate value?
I never claimed that.
That seems like the clearest interpretation of your proposal, nor did you explain what you actually meant when I summarized it and called it a false dichotomy, nor have you explained what you actually meant in this comment either.