It wasn’t the topicness so much as the degree to which the post seemed written in the form of… natter, maybe, would be the word to describe it? It read like Discussion, and not like a main LW post.
I agree, but is the writing style your real objection? If I were an under-rated fAI researcher moderating a website, I’d be annoyed if I saw a main-page post purporting to be humble but still missing the cutting edge of usefulness by several levels of skill. I’d move it to the discussion page by way of emphasizing how far the poster still had to go to be as skilled as I am.
Sure: a third reason might be because leaving low-level posts on friendliness on the top page encourages people to misunderestimate how difficult friendliness is, which might lead them to trivialize the whole project, donate less to SIAI, and/or try to build their own non-provably friendly AI.
The interesting question is why you would remark on writing style if the third reason were your true objection. Maybe you’ve got some other objection altogether—it’s not that important to me; I like your blog and you can move stuff around on it if you feel like it.
It wasn’t the topicness so much as the degree to which the post seemed written in the form of… natter, maybe, would be the word to describe it? It read like Discussion, and not like a main LW post.
I agree, but is the writing style your real objection? If I were an under-rated fAI researcher moderating a website, I’d be annoyed if I saw a main-page post purporting to be humble but still missing the cutting edge of usefulness by several levels of skill. I’d move it to the discussion page by way of emphasizing how far the poster still had to go to be as skilled as I am.
A tad too much cynicism, there. You can’t think of any other reason to move it to the Discussion page, under those circumstances?
Sure: a third reason might be because leaving low-level posts on friendliness on the top page encourages people to misunderestimate how difficult friendliness is, which might lead them to trivialize the whole project, donate less to SIAI, and/or try to build their own non-provably friendly AI.
The interesting question is why you would remark on writing style if the third reason were your true objection. Maybe you’ve got some other objection altogether—it’s not that important to me; I like your blog and you can move stuff around on it if you feel like it.