the resolution criteria of a bet should not rely heavily on reasonableness of participants unless the bet is very small such that both parties can tolerate misresolution. the manifold folks can tell you all about how it goes when you get this wrong, there are many seemingly obvious questions that have been derailed by technicalities, and it was not the author’s reasonableness most centrally at play. (edit: in fact, the author’s reasonableness is why the author had to say “wait… uh… according to those criteria this pretty clearly went x way, which I didn’t expect and so the resolution criteria were wrong”)
the resolution criteria of a bet should not rely heavily on reasonableness of participants unless the bet is very small such that both parties can tolerate misresolution. the manifold folks can tell you all about how it goes when you get this wrong, there are many seemingly obvious questions that have been derailed by technicalities, and it was not the author’s reasonableness most centrally at play. (edit: in fact, the author’s reasonableness is why the author had to say “wait… uh… according to those criteria this pretty clearly went x way, which I didn’t expect and so the resolution criteria were wrong”)