From what I can see, you’re arguing entirely over the definition of ‘knowledge’ instead of just splitting up individual concepts and giving them different names.
I basically agree, we are. What I’m trying to do is to maintain knowledge as a separate thing from belief. I don’t have particular attachment to this definition of knowledge (as pointed out above, “justified true belief” is a little simplistic), but I can’t find any way that jocko’s version is different from straight-up belief.
From what I can see, you’re arguing entirely over the definition of ‘knowledge’ instead of just splitting up individual concepts and giving them different names.
I basically agree, we are. What I’m trying to do is to maintain knowledge as a separate thing from belief. I don’t have particular attachment to this definition of knowledge (as pointed out above, “justified true belief” is a little simplistic), but I can’t find any way that jocko’s version is different from straight-up belief.