This is still happening, right? I once had a professor who suggested that philosophy is basically the process of creating new fields and removing them from philosophy—thence logic, mathematics, physics, and more recently linguistics.
That’s true, I may have overstated his suggestion—the actual context was “why has philosophy made so little progress over the past several thousand years?” (“Because every time a philosophical question is settled, it stops being a philosophical question.”)
This provides a defense of the claim that luke was attacking earlier on the thread, that
“It’s totally reasonable to expect philosophy to provide several interesting/useful results [in one or a few broad subject areas] and then suddenly stop.”
Possibly, yes, but I’d expect philosophy to stop working on a field only after it’s recognized as its own (non-philosophy) area (if then) - which, for example, morality is not.
Errr… it seems to me that theology in many ways acts like philosophy, with the addition of stuff like exegesis and apologetics… but any particular religion’s theology is distinct from the set of things we’d call “philosophy” as a monolithic institution. This is far from my area of expertise, however!
This is still happening, right? I once had a professor who suggested that philosophy is basically the process of creating new fields and removing them from philosophy—thence logic, mathematics, physics, and more recently linguistics.
Thats an interesting definition of philosophy, but I think philosophy does far more than that.
That’s true, I may have overstated his suggestion—the actual context was “why has philosophy made so little progress over the past several thousand years?” (“Because every time a philosophical question is settled, it stops being a philosophical question.”)
This provides a defense of the claim that luke was attacking earlier on the thread, that
“It’s totally reasonable to expect philosophy to provide several interesting/useful results [in one or a few broad subject areas] and then suddenly stop.”
Possibly, yes, but I’d expect philosophy to stop working on a field only after it’s recognized as its own (non-philosophy) area (if then) - which, for example, morality is not.
Is theology a branch of philosophy?
Errr… it seems to me that theology in many ways acts like philosophy, with the addition of stuff like exegesis and apologetics… but any particular religion’s theology is distinct from the set of things we’d call “philosophy” as a monolithic institution. This is far from my area of expertise, however!