Took the survey. Did not read the comments first. Here are my observations after filling it out and reading the comments:
Problems encountered:
I followed the instructions carefully for the digit ratio question. I then went to enter my answer and found that the instructions failed to tell me to image my left hand as well as my right, so I gave the partial answer I had rather than go through all the steps again for the left hand. As of this writing, one other person commented on this problem.
Criticism of questions:
I realize after the fact that when answering “how many books have you read”, I counted only things which are books in the sense of “the kind of thing that has an ISBN”, excluding book-length self-published-on-the-internet documents, and also thought only of new books as opposed to rereads. I request that future versions of this question clarify what counts as a book and whether rereading counts.
“Hours Online”: what counts as “on the Internet” in today’s world is unclear. If I’m writing a book in Google Docs, does that count? If I’m focused on a problem, but I have an IRC channel open in the corner of my screen, does that count? If I’m walking down the street and my phone notifies me of a post which I immediately read, does that count?
Generally: there is a spectrum of plausible interpretations from “performing any activity which requires a functioning Internet connection” (broad definition) to “aimless web surfing” (narrow definition).
“Moral Views” could benefit from links to definitions.
“Hours Online”: what counts as “on the Internet” in today’s world is unclear. If I’m writing a book in Google Docs, does that count? If I’m focused on a problem, but I have an IRC channel open in the corner of my screen, does that count? If I’m walking down the street and my phone notifies me of a post which I immediately read, does that count?
I used the statistic for my “Everything” block set on LeechBlock, which amounts to interpreting “the Internet” as “the WWW”, but I now realize that maybe time spent reading/writing e-mails and/or on the Facebook Messenger app on my phone should also count.
Took the survey. Did not read the comments first. Here are my observations after filling it out and reading the comments:
Problems encountered:
I followed the instructions carefully for the digit ratio question. I then went to enter my answer and found that the instructions failed to tell me to image my left hand as well as my right, so I gave the partial answer I had rather than go through all the steps again for the left hand. As of this writing, one other person commented on this problem.
Criticism of questions:
I realize after the fact that when answering “how many books have you read”, I counted only things which are books in the sense of “the kind of thing that has an ISBN”, excluding book-length self-published-on-the-internet documents, and also thought only of new books as opposed to rereads. I request that future versions of this question clarify what counts as a book and whether rereading counts.
“Hours Online”: what counts as “on the Internet” in today’s world is unclear. If I’m writing a book in Google Docs, does that count? If I’m focused on a problem, but I have an IRC channel open in the corner of my screen, does that count? If I’m walking down the street and my phone notifies me of a post which I immediately read, does that count?
Generally: there is a spectrum of plausible interpretations from “performing any activity which requires a functioning Internet connection” (broad definition) to “aimless web surfing” (narrow definition).
“Moral Views” could benefit from links to definitions.
I used the statistic for my “Everything” block set on LeechBlock, which amounts to interpreting “the Internet” as “the WWW”, but I now realize that maybe time spent reading/writing e-mails and/or on the Facebook Messenger app on my phone should also count.