This is not the noncentral fallacy. This is me pointing out that the hypothetical argument I’m responding to proves too much.
Basically the problem with arguments of the form doing X gives pleasure therefore we should do more X, is that the same argument applies to wireheading. If you have no better reply than wireheading seems ewe and X doesn’t, keep in mind that your intuitions about what is ewe change depending on what you do.
This is not the noncentral fallacy. This is me pointing out that the hypothetical argument I’m responding to proves too much.
Basically the problem with arguments of the form doing X gives pleasure therefore we should do more X, is that the same argument applies to wireheading. If you have no better reply than wireheading seems ewe and X doesn’t, keep in mind that your intuitions about what is ewe change depending on what you do.