Buck Shlegeris, Ethan Perez, Evan Hubinger, and Owain Evans are mentoring in both programs. The links show their MATS projects, “personal fit” for applicants, and (where applicable) applicant selection questions, designed to mimic the research experience.
Astra seems like an obviously better choice for applicants principally interested in:
AI governance: MATS has no AI governance mentors in the Winter 2023-24 Program, whereas Astra has Daniel Kokotajlo, Richard Ngo, and associated staff at ARC Evals and Open Phil;
Worldview investigations: Astra has Ajeya Cotra, Tom Davidson, and Lukas Finnvedan, whereas MATS has no Open Phil mentors;
ARC Evals: While both programs feature mentors working on evals, only Astra is working with ARC Evals;
Buck Shlegeris, Ethan Perez, Evan Hubinger, and Owain Evans are mentoring in both programs. The links show their MATS projects, “personal fit” for applicants, and (where applicable) applicant selection questions, designed to mimic the research experience.
Astra seems like an obviously better choice for applicants principally interested in:
AI governance: MATS has no AI governance mentors in the Winter 2023-24 Program, whereas Astra has Daniel Kokotajlo, Richard Ngo, and associated staff at ARC Evals and Open Phil;
Worldview investigations: Astra has Ajeya Cotra, Tom Davidson, and Lukas Finnvedan, whereas MATS has no Open Phil mentors;
ARC Evals: While both programs feature mentors working on evals, only Astra is working with ARC Evals;
AI ethics: Astra is working with Rob Long.