We are talking about time travel and so this doesn’t apply. Your comment is nitpicky for no good reason. I obviously recognize that consequentialists believe that more lives are better; I don’t know why you felt an urge to tell me that. Your wording is also unnecessarily pedantic and inefficient.
Sure. Again, this isn’t relevant and isn’t providing information that’s new to me. People like Schopenhauer and Benatar might exist, but surely my overall point still stands. The focus on nitpicking is excessive and frustrating. I don’t want to have to invest much time and effort into my comments on this site so that I can avoid allowing people to get distracted by side issues; I want to get my points across as efficiently as possible and without interruption.
I was thinking more of average utilitarians than antinatalists. (I provisionally agree with average utilitarianism, and think more lives are better instrumentally but not terminally. I’m not confident that I wouldn’t change my mind if I thought this stuff through, though.)
We are talking about time travel and so this doesn’t apply. Your comment is nitpicky for no good reason. I obviously recognize that consequentialists believe that more lives are better; I don’t know why you felt an urge to tell me that. Your wording is also unnecessarily pedantic and inefficient.
Not all of them.
Sure. Again, this isn’t relevant and isn’t providing information that’s new to me. People like Schopenhauer and Benatar might exist, but surely my overall point still stands. The focus on nitpicking is excessive and frustrating. I don’t want to have to invest much time and effort into my comments on this site so that I can avoid allowing people to get distracted by side issues; I want to get my points across as efficiently as possible and without interruption.
I was thinking more of average utilitarians than antinatalists. (I provisionally agree with average utilitarianism, and think more lives are better instrumentally but not terminally. I’m not confident that I wouldn’t change my mind if I thought this stuff through, though.)