Do Timeless Decision Theory and Updateless Decision Theory say you have a counterfactual obligation to create Bob the Jerk, the same way you have an obligation to pay Omega in the Counterfactual Mugging, and the same way you might (I’m still not sure about this) have an obligation to one-box when dealing with Prometheus?
If you find that your decision theory creates an obligation to lose, you need a better decision theory.
If you find that your decision theory creates an obligation to lose, you need a better decision theory.