Remark: It is hard to know what to make of a comment that has a decently positive approval score, a substantially negative agreement score, and no comments expressing disagreement. Clearly … hmm, actually, clearly one person strong-agreement-downvoted it and chose not to say what they didn’t like. So all I know is that of the several lines of argument in the lengthy comment above, something seemed very bad to someone.
It’s not for me to tell anyone else what they ought to do, but personally I think that if I were strong-agreement-downvoting something and it wasn’t perfectly obvious what might be wrong with it, then I would also want to leave a comment saying what I thought was wrong. (Maybe not if I thought the writer was an aggressive bozo who shouldn’t be responded to, or something.)
Remark: It is hard to know what to make of a comment that has a decently positive approval score, a substantially negative agreement score, and no comments expressing disagreement. Clearly … hmm, actually, clearly one person strong-agreement-downvoted it and chose not to say what they didn’t like. So all I know is that of the several lines of argument in the lengthy comment above, something seemed very bad to someone.
It’s not for me to tell anyone else what they ought to do, but personally I think that if I were strong-agreement-downvoting something and it wasn’t perfectly obvious what might be wrong with it, then I would also want to leave a comment saying what I thought was wrong. (Maybe not if I thought the writer was an aggressive bozo who shouldn’t be responded to, or something.)
I expressed some disagreement in my comment, but I didn’t disagree-vote.
It seemed pretty clear from the text of your comment that you didn’t think mine deserved a strong disagree-vote.