When first reading the AI-Box experiment a year ago, I reasoned that if you follow the rules and spirit of the experiment, the gatekeeper must be convinced to knowingly give you $X and knowingly show gullibility. From that perspective, it’s impossible. And even if you could do it, that would mean you’ve solved a “human-psychology-complete” problem and then [insert point about SIAI funding and possibly about why you don’t have 12 supermodel girlfriends].
Now, I think I see the answer. Basically, Eliezer_Yudkowsky doesn’t really have to convince the gatekeeper to stupidly give away $X. All he has to do is convince them that “It would be a good thing if people saw that the result of this AI-Box experiment was that the human got tricked, because that would stimulate interest in {Friendliness, AGI, the Singularity}, and that interest would be a good thing.”
That, it seems, is the one thing that would make people give up $X in such a circumstance. AFAICT, it adheres to the spirit of the set-up since the gatekeeper’s decision would be completely voluntary.
When first reading the AI-Box experiment a year ago, I reasoned that if you follow the rules and spirit of the experiment, the gatekeeper must be convinced to knowingly give you $X and knowingly show gullibility. From that perspective, it’s impossible. And even if you could do it, that would mean you’ve solved a “human-psychology-complete” problem and then [insert point about SIAI funding and possibly about why you don’t have 12 supermodel girlfriends].
Now, I think I see the answer. Basically, Eliezer_Yudkowsky doesn’t really have to convince the gatekeeper to stupidly give away $X. All he has to do is convince them that “It would be a good thing if people saw that the result of this AI-Box experiment was that the human got tricked, because that would stimulate interest in {Friendliness, AGI, the Singularity}, and that interest would be a good thing.”
That, it seems, is the one thing that would make people give up $X in such a circumstance. AFAICT, it adheres to the spirit of the set-up since the gatekeeper’s decision would be completely voluntary.
I can send my salary requirements.