Ok, I now have at least a sketch of an example. I haven’t worked it out in detail, so I may be wrong, but here is what I think. In any scenario in which you gain and act on information after the planning stage, you should not use a recalculated planning-stage solution for any decisions after you have acted upon that information. Instead, you need to do the action-optimal analysis.
For example, let us complicate the absent-minded driver scenario that you diagrammed by adding an information-receipt and decision node prior to those two identical intersections. The driver comes in from the west and arrives at a T intersection where he can turn left(north) or right(south). At the intersection is a billboard advertising today’s lunch menu at Casa de Maria, his favorite restaurant. If the billboard promotes chile, he will want to turn right so as to have a good chance of reaching Maria’s for lunch. But if the billboard promotes enchiladas, which he dislikes, he probably wants to turn the other way and try for Marcello’s Pizza. Whether he turns right or left at the billboard, he will face two consecutive identical intersections (four identical intersections total). The day is cloudy, so he cannot tell whether he is traveling north or south.
Working this example in detail will take some work. Let me know if you think the work is necessary.
Ok, I now have at least a sketch of an example. I haven’t worked it out in detail, so I may be wrong, but here is what I think. In any scenario in which you gain and act on information after the planning stage, you should not use a recalculated planning-stage solution for any decisions after you have acted upon that information. Instead, you need to do the action-optimal analysis.
For example, let us complicate the absent-minded driver scenario that you diagrammed by adding an information-receipt and decision node prior to those two identical intersections. The driver comes in from the west and arrives at a T intersection where he can turn left(north) or right(south). At the intersection is a billboard advertising today’s lunch menu at Casa de Maria, his favorite restaurant. If the billboard promotes chile, he will want to turn right so as to have a good chance of reaching Maria’s for lunch. But if the billboard promotes enchiladas, which he dislikes, he probably wants to turn the other way and try for Marcello’s Pizza. Whether he turns right or left at the billboard, he will face two consecutive identical intersections (four identical intersections total). The day is cloudy, so he cannot tell whether he is traveling north or south.
Working this example in detail will take some work. Let me know if you think the work is necessary.