Where relevant—or at least when I’m reminded of it—I do model myself as a collection of smaller agents. But I still call that collection “I”, even though it’s not unique, coherent, or consistent. That my identity may be a group-identity doesn’t seem to modify any of my conclusions about identity, given that to date the group has always resided together in a single brain.
For my own part, I find that attending to the fact that I am a non-unique, incoherent, and inconsistent collection of disparate agents significantly reduces how seriously I take concerns that some process might fail to properly capture the mysterious essence of “I”, leading to my putative duplicate going off and having fun in a virtual Utopia while “I” remains in a cancer-ridden body.
I would gladly be uploaded rather than die if there were no alternative. I would still pay extra for a process that slowly replaced my brain cells etc. one by one leaving me conscious and single-instanced the whole while.
Where relevant—or at least when I’m reminded of it—I do model myself as a collection of smaller agents. But I still call that collection “I”, even though it’s not unique, coherent, or consistent. That my identity may be a group-identity doesn’t seem to modify any of my conclusions about identity, given that to date the group has always resided together in a single brain.
For my own part, I find that attending to the fact that I am a non-unique, incoherent, and inconsistent collection of disparate agents significantly reduces how seriously I take concerns that some process might fail to properly capture the mysterious essence of “I”, leading to my putative duplicate going off and having fun in a virtual Utopia while “I” remains in a cancer-ridden body.
I would gladly be uploaded rather than die if there were no alternative. I would still pay extra for a process that slowly replaced my brain cells etc. one by one leaving me conscious and single-instanced the whole while.
That sounds superficially like a cruel and unusual torture.
The whole point is to invent an uploading process I wouldn’t even notice happening.