I see. I was trying to do was answer your terminology question by addressing simple extreme cases. e.g. if you ask an AI to disconnect its shutdown button, I don’t think it’s being incorrigible. If you ask an AI to keep you safe, and then it disconnects its shutdown button, it is being incorrigible.
I think the main way the religion case differs is that the AI system is interfering with our intellectual ability for strategizing about AI rather than our physical systems for redirecting AI, and I’m not sure how that counts. But if I ask an AI to keep me safe and it mind-controls me to want to propagate that AI, that’s sure incorrigible. Maybe, as you suggest, it’s just fundamentally ill-defined...
I see. I was trying to do was answer your terminology question by addressing simple extreme cases. e.g. if you ask an AI to disconnect its shutdown button, I don’t think it’s being incorrigible. If you ask an AI to keep you safe, and then it disconnects its shutdown button, it is being incorrigible.
I think the main way the religion case differs is that the AI system is interfering with our intellectual ability for strategizing about AI rather than our physical systems for redirecting AI, and I’m not sure how that counts. But if I ask an AI to keep me safe and it mind-controls me to want to propagate that AI, that’s sure incorrigible. Maybe, as you suggest, it’s just fundamentally ill-defined...