Yeah, I was responding to your original claim that none of the questions here have any link to anticipated experience. Your claim here—that philosophy does not produce any knowledge of use to other disciplines—is a different criticism, and one that my comment was not intended to address. I think this criticism is also false, by the way. Well, it may be true in the sense that as a matter of fact very few people in other disciplines pay much attention to contemporary philosophy, but it is false that there is nothing of value in philosophy for these other disciplines.
Yeah, I was responding to your original claim that none of the questions here have any link to anticipated experience. Your claim here—that philosophy does not produce any knowledge of use to other disciplines—is a different criticism, and one that my comment was not intended to address. I think this criticism is also false, by the way. Well, it may be true in the sense that as a matter of fact very few people in other disciplines pay much attention to contemporary philosophy, but it is false that there is nothing of value in philosophy for these other disciplines.