Perhaps I should further specify just what sort of spaces I’m clear and unclear on. (All “maybe”s, “probably”s refer to my own uncertainty, of course—for simplicity I’m doing writing this as if I hadn’t read any of the cousin posts yet.) The examples listed here are whatever I think of, mostly relevant ones but not all—I don’t think there’s a zoo anywhere around here and I haven’t been to one in quite some time, but the example occurred to me while I was writing this so I threw it in. I expect I’m right about the things I’m certain of but should that not be the case corrections would be appreciated!
Definitely OK to approach people: “Private public spaces”—anywhere where a person you don’t know can be assumed to be a friend of a friend—small parties, common rooms in dorms or co-op houses
OK to join existing conversations, maybe not OK to approach people initially: “Purposed public spaces”—anywhere where a person you don’t know can be assumed to share a common interest—a common room in a school department building, e.g. Game stores probably fit here too. Also probably competitions of any sort.
Probably OK but currently avoided by me: Outside—on the street, on the quad, in the park. Here the location doesn’t let you infer much of anything. (Unless something unusual is occurring, then clearly OK as people gather around it.)
???: Fast-food places or food courts. Non-quiet spaces where people go to get work done (but which are too general to fall under #2.) Zoos, museums, other similar places. Bookstores.
Probably not OK: Libraries.
Definitely not OK: Anywhere where you shouldn’t be talking in the first place. Most restaurants.
Again, thanks! The sibling posts have already clarified things some.
My suggestion: take a crash course in etiquette by going to another city nearby, and then spend a few days walking around asking questions, or inviting people to do stuff with you, etc. Condition yourself to get used to the occasional weird look, learn what you can get away with, and possibly make friends with people you would otherwise never meet.
If all else fails, drive out of the city and pretend the entire thing never happened. Or you will get some amusing stories to share with me when you get back.
How can you lose?
I am only partly joking, my social skills are so mediocre I have seriously considered doing exactly this at some point. I might throw in some speed dating as well for good measure.
A current example is my temporary move to Boston/Cambridge. I’ve walked around asking random strangers questions such as “If you could live anywhere in Boston, where would you live?”
I’ve received great advice, and made a few friendships and event invites from doing so!
I can’t tell if people actually don’t care or if they are just oblivious, but I hate when people try to strike up a conversation while I’m using a public toilet. Bad when it’s a urinal, worse when it’s a stall. Maybe this falls under “spaces where people go to get work done”?
In ambiguous environments, it is best to determine ok-ness on the basis of the people.
Good situations:
You are both doing the same thing—looking at the same genre of books in a bookstore, the same exhibit in a museum or zoo, both walking dogs in a park etc. This makes it easier to talk as you already have one thing in common and you can comment on that to see if they are receptive to conversation.
Something unusual happens—a delay on public transport, something wacky is going on in the quad etc
If you mean quad as in university, you already have a thing in common—you’re at the same university. It is likely to be okay to strike up a conversation.
They’re waiting for something. In a queue or waiting for public transport etc—may be bored
They’re having a cigarette—they probably have time for a quick chat and if you smoke too there’s a kind of unspoken thing with smokers where they will have a chat
Presence of alcohol but not a restaurant
Bad signs:
Person is wearing headphones or reading—they are busy and unlikely to want to talk
They are a woman under 40-ish and you are a dude: potential difficulties, see below.
-
So there is a thing with a guy approaching a strange woman—she is likely to inductively infer that you are not just after a friendly chat. The best thing to do is use caution and watch for signals that she doesn’t want to be approached and be ready to back off if your intentions are misinterpreted. A good thing to do here is to make sure that it is immediately obvious that you are talking about something that is not her—comment on your shared situation ahead of saying anything like ‘hello’ or ‘how you doing’. Commenting on the books or the museum exhibit or something like that lets her know that you’re looking at that, not her tits.
“Highly variable” is not particularly helpful but I suppose if it’s true then there might not be much more to say.
Regarding variability:
Are you in a section of the library where talking is forbidden? Probably don’t talk there unless you wish to flaunt rulebreaking.
Don’t interrupt people when they are thoroughly engrossed in reading a book or look like they are fully focussed on getting their assignment finished by 5:30. Do talk to people if they look more relaxed or generally not busy.
“Obvious” kind of stuff, for a suitable value of obvious. (Also ‘obvious’ is that you could probably talk to even the busy folks if you are particularly charming or appear high status. That’s how social rules work.)
The “don’t” part was pretty obvious to me, and generalizes to other places, the “do” part was not. :) I would have assumed people in libraries probably want to be left alone.
Perhaps I should further specify just what sort of spaces I’m clear and unclear on. (All “maybe”s, “probably”s refer to my own uncertainty, of course—for simplicity I’m doing writing this as if I hadn’t read any of the cousin posts yet.) The examples listed here are whatever I think of, mostly relevant ones but not all—I don’t think there’s a zoo anywhere around here and I haven’t been to one in quite some time, but the example occurred to me while I was writing this so I threw it in. I expect I’m right about the things I’m certain of but should that not be the case corrections would be appreciated!
Definitely OK to approach people: “Private public spaces”—anywhere where a person you don’t know can be assumed to be a friend of a friend—small parties, common rooms in dorms or co-op houses
OK to join existing conversations, maybe not OK to approach people initially: “Purposed public spaces”—anywhere where a person you don’t know can be assumed to share a common interest—a common room in a school department building, e.g. Game stores probably fit here too. Also probably competitions of any sort.
Probably OK but currently avoided by me: Outside—on the street, on the quad, in the park. Here the location doesn’t let you infer much of anything. (Unless something unusual is occurring, then clearly OK as people gather around it.)
???: Fast-food places or food courts. Non-quiet spaces where people go to get work done (but which are too general to fall under #2.) Zoos, museums, other similar places. Bookstores.
Probably not OK: Libraries.
Definitely not OK: Anywhere where you shouldn’t be talking in the first place. Most restaurants.
Again, thanks! The sibling posts have already clarified things some.
My suggestion: take a crash course in etiquette by going to another city nearby, and then spend a few days walking around asking questions, or inviting people to do stuff with you, etc. Condition yourself to get used to the occasional weird look, learn what you can get away with, and possibly make friends with people you would otherwise never meet. If all else fails, drive out of the city and pretend the entire thing never happened. Or you will get some amusing stories to share with me when you get back. How can you lose?
I am only partly joking, my social skills are so mediocre I have seriously considered doing exactly this at some point. I might throw in some speed dating as well for good measure.
I do this all the time, with fantastic results!
A current example is my temporary move to Boston/Cambridge. I’ve walked around asking random strangers questions such as “If you could live anywhere in Boston, where would you live?”
I’ve received great advice, and made a few friendships and event invites from doing so!
I endorse this advice wholeheartedly.
I can’t tell if people actually don’t care or if they are just oblivious, but I hate when people try to strike up a conversation while I’m using a public toilet. Bad when it’s a urinal, worse when it’s a stall. Maybe this falls under “spaces where people go to get work done”?
In ambiguous environments, it is best to determine ok-ness on the basis of the people.
Good situations: You are both doing the same thing—looking at the same genre of books in a bookstore, the same exhibit in a museum or zoo, both walking dogs in a park etc. This makes it easier to talk as you already have one thing in common and you can comment on that to see if they are receptive to conversation.
Something unusual happens—a delay on public transport, something wacky is going on in the quad etc
If you mean quad as in university, you already have a thing in common—you’re at the same university. It is likely to be okay to strike up a conversation.
They’re waiting for something. In a queue or waiting for public transport etc—may be bored
They’re having a cigarette—they probably have time for a quick chat and if you smoke too there’s a kind of unspoken thing with smokers where they will have a chat
Presence of alcohol but not a restaurant
Bad signs: Person is wearing headphones or reading—they are busy and unlikely to want to talk
They are a woman under 40-ish and you are a dude: potential difficulties, see below.
-
So there is a thing with a guy approaching a strange woman—she is likely to inductively infer that you are not just after a friendly chat. The best thing to do is use caution and watch for signals that she doesn’t want to be approached and be ready to back off if your intentions are misinterpreted. A good thing to do here is to make sure that it is immediately obvious that you are talking about something that is not her—comment on your shared situation ahead of saying anything like ‘hello’ or ‘how you doing’. Commenting on the books or the museum exhibit or something like that lets her know that you’re looking at that, not her tits.
I don’t agree with this one. It is highly variable.
OK, good to know. “Highly variable” is not particularly helpful but I suppose if it’s true then there might not be much more to say.
Regarding variability:
Are you in a section of the library where talking is forbidden? Probably don’t talk there unless you wish to flaunt rulebreaking.
Don’t interrupt people when they are thoroughly engrossed in reading a book or look like they are fully focussed on getting their assignment finished by 5:30. Do talk to people if they look more relaxed or generally not busy.
“Obvious” kind of stuff, for a suitable value of obvious. (Also ‘obvious’ is that you could probably talk to even the busy folks if you are particularly charming or appear high status. That’s how social rules work.)
The “don’t” part was pretty obvious to me, and generalizes to other places, the “do” part was not. :) I would have assumed people in libraries probably want to be left alone.