It’s harder to work out an example of evidence turning out to be much stronger than is claimed
Not particularly difficult, just posit a person who prior experience has taught you is particularly unreliable about assessing evidence. If they post a link arguing a position you already know they’re in favor of, you should assign a relatively low weight of evidence to the knowledge that they’ve linked to a resource arguing the position, but if you check it out and find that it’s actually well researched and reasoned, then you update upwards.
Not particularly difficult, just posit a person who prior experience has taught you is particularly unreliable about assessing evidence. If they post a link arguing a position you already know they’re in favor of, you should assign a relatively low weight of evidence to the knowledge that they’ve linked to a resource arguing the position, but if you check it out and find that it’s actually well researched and reasoned, then you update upwards.