Purple fire accused me of having an arrogant tone and he/she is assuming that I’m the one who wrote the essay. Neither of those assumptions are true, and I was simply pointing that out.
There’s nothing wrong with posting an essay to see what other people think about it. I never claimed to be an expert on economics.
There’s no way for anyone to know that you didn’t write the essay unless they already know that your username isn’t an alias of the writer. You didn’t write “here is a post by someone else” or anything else which makes clear that the post is not yours, let alone that you don’t endorse it. In fact the essay starts with “In this essay, I will”, making the normal assumption that the only person whose username is attached to the post is who “I” refers to.
This post is a link post that links to the TheWaywardAxolotl.
I figured that more people would read the essay if the text was displayed directly on LessWrong, so I copied the text from the blog post and pasted it into the LessWrong post.
The author has said that he doesn’t mind people doing this as long as they include a link back to his blog.
I’m sure I’m not the only one on this forum who shares content that I didn’t write myself.
It’s pretty normal to do that on social media.
There’s no way for anyone to know that you didn’t write the essay unless they already know that your username isn’t an alias of the writer.
My user profile has a link to zerocontradictions.net, which is clearly my website.
That URL is shown when anybody hovers over my username on this site.
This link post links to the TheWaywardAxolotl, which is clearly a different website.
The username on that blog is also displayed as “Blithering Genius”, not “Zero Contradictions”.
There is nothing on Blithering Genius’s blog to suggest that I own it, so it’s weird that Purple fire is jumping to the assumption that I wrote the essay.
making the normal assumption that the only person whose username is attached to the post is who “I” refers to.
Yes, that’s how the essay appears on TheWaywardAxolotl, which is clearly not my blog.
It’s also how it appears on this LessWrong post, since I copied the text into the post.
“I” and “we” are used throughout the essay, so it’s not easy to edit out the first-person language.
But since you insist, I edited the post to include a disclaimer at the top that I didn’t write the essay and I’ll do that in the future as well.
let alone that you don’t endorse it
I agree with the essay, but I’m also open-minded, so I shared it to see what other people would say about it, because it’s possible that some people have knowledge and thoughts that I hadn’t thought about.
I think that purple fire made some interesting criticisms which might be right, so I told him/her that he/she should post them on the author’s blog if he/she wants the author to read them.
I didn’t write this post. I’m just sharing it. If you want the author to read your comments, then you should post them on his blog.
If you’re sharing it, but don’t endorse it, you should say that you don’t endorse it. If not, readers have a right to assume that you endorse it.
(And you seem to be in this limbo where you’re sort of endorsing it but sort of not.)
Purple fire accused me of having an arrogant tone and he/she is assuming that I’m the one who wrote the essay. Neither of those assumptions are true, and I was simply pointing that out.
There’s nothing wrong with posting an essay to see what other people think about it. I never claimed to be an expert on economics.
There’s no way for anyone to know that you didn’t write the essay unless they already know that your username isn’t an alias of the writer. You didn’t write “here is a post by someone else” or anything else which makes clear that the post is not yours, let alone that you don’t endorse it. In fact the essay starts with “In this essay, I will”, making the normal assumption that the only person whose username is attached to the post is who “I” refers to.
This post is a link post that links to the TheWaywardAxolotl. I figured that more people would read the essay if the text was displayed directly on LessWrong, so I copied the text from the blog post and pasted it into the LessWrong post. The author has said that he doesn’t mind people doing this as long as they include a link back to his blog. I’m sure I’m not the only one on this forum who shares content that I didn’t write myself. It’s pretty normal to do that on social media.
My user profile has a link to zerocontradictions.net, which is clearly my website. That URL is shown when anybody hovers over my username on this site. This link post links to the TheWaywardAxolotl, which is clearly a different website. The username on that blog is also displayed as “Blithering Genius”, not “Zero Contradictions”. There is nothing on Blithering Genius’s blog to suggest that I own it, so it’s weird that Purple fire is jumping to the assumption that I wrote the essay.
Yes, that’s how the essay appears on TheWaywardAxolotl, which is clearly not my blog. It’s also how it appears on this LessWrong post, since I copied the text into the post. “I” and “we” are used throughout the essay, so it’s not easy to edit out the first-person language. But since you insist, I edited the post to include a disclaimer at the top that I didn’t write the essay and I’ll do that in the future as well.
I agree with the essay, but I’m also open-minded, so I shared it to see what other people would say about it, because it’s possible that some people have knowledge and thoughts that I hadn’t thought about. I think that purple fire made some interesting criticisms which might be right, so I told him/her that he/she should post them on the author’s blog if he/she wants the author to read them.