i’m wary about it. like, how alien is this idealised human? why does it have any moral authority?
I don’t have great answers to these metaethical questions. Conditional on normative realism, it seems plausible to me that first-order normative views must satisfy the vNM axioms. Conditional on normative antirealism, I agree it is less clear that first-order normative views must satisfy the vNM axioms, but this is just a special case of it being hard to justify any normative views under normative antirealism.
In any case, I suspect that we are close to reaching bedrock in this discussion, so perhaps this is a good place to end the discussion.
Thanks!
I don’t have great answers to these metaethical questions. Conditional on normative realism, it seems plausible to me that first-order normative views must satisfy the vNM axioms. Conditional on normative antirealism, I agree it is less clear that first-order normative views must satisfy the vNM axioms, but this is just a special case of it being hard to justify any normative views under normative antirealism.
In any case, I suspect that we are close to reaching bedrock in this discussion, so perhaps this is a good place to end the discussion.