It seems like it would be useful to have it for top-level posts. I love disagree voting and there are massive disparities sometimes between upvotes and agreements that show how useful it is in surfacing good arguments that are controversial.
I think I’m seeing some high effort, topical and well-researched top-level posts die on the vine because of controversial takes that are probably disagree voting. This is not a complaint about my own posts sometimes dying; I’ve been watching others posts with this hypothesis, and it fits.
It seems like it would be useful to have it for top-level posts. I love disagree voting and there are massive disparities sometimes between upvotes and agreements that show how useful it is in surfacing good arguments that are controversial.
I think I’m seeing some high effort, topical and well-researched top-level posts die on the vine because of controversial takes that are probably disagree voting. This is not a complaint about my own posts sometimes dying; I’ve been watching others posts with this hypothesis, and it fits.