Inline agree/disagree reacts are trying to do the equivalent. Comments are short enough that usually you can summarize your epistemic state with regards to their contents into a single “agree or disagree”, but for posts I feel like it really mostly sets things up for polarization and misunderstandings to have a bunch of people “agree” and “disagree” to a huge bundle of claims and statements.
I think it’s better for people to highlight specific passages of text and then react to those.
Do you know the reasons? It seems like it would be useful to have it on top-level posts for the same reasons it’s so helpful on comments.
IDK the reasons.
Inline agree/disagree reacts are trying to do the equivalent. Comments are short enough that usually you can summarize your epistemic state with regards to their contents into a single “agree or disagree”, but for posts I feel like it really mostly sets things up for polarization and misunderstandings to have a bunch of people “agree” and “disagree” to a huge bundle of claims and statements.
I think it’s better for people to highlight specific passages of text and then react to those.
Ooh. That makes a lot of sense and is even better… I simply didn’t realize there were inline reacts! Kudos.