Yeah, CarlSchulman put up a couple of threads on Newcomb a couple weeks ago, here and here. The original Newcomb’s Problem and Regret of Rationality thread has also been getting some traffic recently.
Offhand I don’t see anything in this thread that hasn’t been covered by those, but I may be missing relevant subtleties; I don’t find this debate especially interesting past the first few rounds.
Yeah, CarlSchulman put up a couple of threads on Newcomb a couple weeks ago, here and here. The original Newcomb’s Problem and Regret of Rationality thread has also been getting some traffic recently.
Offhand I don’t see anything in this thread that hasn’t been covered by those, but I may be missing relevant subtleties; I don’t find this debate especially interesting past the first few rounds.