As the OP said, Eliezer hasn’t been subpoenaed. The questions here are merely stimulus to which he can respond with whichever insights or signals he desires to convey. For what little it is worth my 1.58 bits is ‘up’.
(At least, if it is granted that a given person has read a post and that his voting decision is made actively then I think I would count it as 1.58 bits. It’s a little blurry.)
As the OP said, Eliezer hasn’t been subpoenaed. The questions here are merely stimulus to which he can respond with whichever insights or signals he desires to convey. For what little it is worth my 1.58 bits is ‘up’.
(At least, if it is granted that a given person has read a post and that his voting decision is made actively then I think I would count it as 1.58 bits. It’s a little blurry.)
It depends on the probability distribution of comments.
Good point. Probability distribution of comments relative to those doing the evaluation.