For what it’s worth, I wrote a critique of Shard Theory here on LessWrong (on Oct 20, 2022) from the perspective of behavior genetics and the heritability of values.
The comments include some helpful replies and discussions with Shard Theory developers Quintin Pope and Alex Trout.
For what it’s worth, I wrote a critique of Shard Theory here on LessWrong (on Oct 20, 2022) from the perspective of behavior genetics and the heritability of values.
The comments include some helpful replies and discussions with Shard Theory developers Quintin Pope and Alex Trout.
I’d welcome any other feedback as well.