Fair enough. But I think you threw a wide net over the problem. To the extend you are unhappy that noobs are “spouting garbage that’s been discussed to death” and aren’t being sufficiently punished for it, you could say that instead. If that’s not what you are concerned about, then I have failed to comprehend your message.
Exclusivity might solve the problem of noobs rehashing old topics from the beginning (and I certainly agree that needing to tell everyone that beliefs must make predictions about the future gets old very fast). But it would have multiple knock-on effects that you have not even acknowledged. My intuition is that evaporative cooling would be bad for this community, but your sense may differ.
Fair enough. But I think you threw a wide net over the problem. To the extend you are unhappy that noobs are “spouting garbage that’s been discussed to death” and aren’t being sufficiently punished for it, you could say that instead. If that’s not what you are concerned about, then I have failed to comprehend your message.
Exclusivity might solve the problem of noobs rehashing old topics from the beginning (and I certainly agree that needing to tell everyone that beliefs must make predictions about the future gets old very fast). But it would have multiple knock-on effects that you have not even acknowledged. My intuition is that evaporative cooling would be bad for this community, but your sense may differ.