I don’t know whether thomblake intended the latter, but he certainly didn’t say the former. I think you said “Eliezer said A and B”, thomblake said “No he didn’t”, and you are now saying he meant “Eliezer said neither A nor B”. I suggest that he said, or at least implied, something rather like A, and would fiercely repudiate B.
I don’t know whether thomblake intended the latter, but he certainly didn’t say the former. I think you said “Eliezer said A and B”, thomblake said “No he didn’t”, and you are now saying he meant “Eliezer said neither A nor B”. I suggest that he said, or at least implied, something rather like A, and would fiercely repudiate B.