There’s also the question of the non-helper as an instance of a class, and you as an instance of a class, and the resulting implied ecology. Or to say it a different way: apply TDT to the shadowmoth / meal question. To say it a third way: if people like me react to situations like this—involving some relationship with someone or something—in such-and-such a way, then what trophic niche are we opening up, i.e. what sort of food are we making available for what sort of predator?
I had had individual thoughts like “of course in this case the alien woman is, you know, bad for kidnapping him and torturing him”, but the particular ecosystem frame feels probably-useful for generating followup questions. (It’s also thematically resonant with the themes in the book!)
This thread did motivate me to add an additional disclaimer to the post.
There’s also the question of the non-helper as an instance of a class, and you as an instance of a class, and the resulting implied ecology. Or to say it a different way: apply TDT to the shadowmoth / meal question. To say it a third way: if people like me react to situations like this—involving some relationship with someone or something—in such-and-such a way, then what trophic niche are we opening up, i.e. what sort of food are we making available for what sort of predator?
I found this a particularly helpful lens.
I had had individual thoughts like “of course in this case the alien woman is, you know, bad for kidnapping him and torturing him”, but the particular ecosystem frame feels probably-useful for generating followup questions. (It’s also thematically resonant with the themes in the book!)
This thread did motivate me to add an additional disclaimer to the post.