I’ve actually come to a remarkably similar conclusion as described in this post. We’re phrasing things differently (I called it the “myth of general intelligence”), but I think we’re getting at the same thing. The Secret of Our Success has been very influential on my thinking as well.
This is also my biggest point of contention with Yudkowsky’s views. He seems to suggest (for example, in this post) that capabilities are gained from being able to think well and a lot. In my opinion he vastly underestimates the amount of data/experience required to make that possible in the first place, for any particular capability or domain. This speaks to the age-old (classical) rationalism vs empiricism debate, where Yudkowsky seems to sit on the rationalist side, whereas it seems you and I would lean more to the empiricist side.
I think the Secrets of our Success goes too far, and I’m less willing to rely on it than you, but I do think it got at least a significant share of how humans learn right (like 30-50% at minimum).
Thank you for the reply!
I’ve actually come to a remarkably similar conclusion as described in this post. We’re phrasing things differently (I called it the “myth of general intelligence”), but I think we’re getting at the same thing. The Secret of Our Success has been very influential on my thinking as well.
This is also my biggest point of contention with Yudkowsky’s views. He seems to suggest (for example, in this post) that capabilities are gained from being able to think well and a lot. In my opinion he vastly underestimates the amount of data/experience required to make that possible in the first place, for any particular capability or domain. This speaks to the age-old (classical) rationalism vs empiricism debate, where Yudkowsky seems to sit on the rationalist side, whereas it seems you and I would lean more to the empiricist side.
I think the Secrets of our Success goes too far, and I’m less willing to rely on it than you, but I do think it got at least a significant share of how humans learn right (like 30-50% at minimum).