Update: I’m shifting towards thinking that peer-review could be good if done right, because:
I’m told it does work well in practice some times, creating a proof of concept.
I can see how being asked specifically to review some specific work could make me motivated to put in more work than I would do in a more public format (talk or blogpost).
Update: I’m shifting towards thinking that peer-review could be good if done right, because:
I’m told it does work well in practice some times, creating a proof of concept.
I can see how being asked specifically to review some specific work could make me motivated to put in more work than I would do in a more public format (talk or blogpost).