Can you clarify how “Wanting to steal something is a natural human reaction if a person is treated unfairly” is not a factual question? I mean, I suppose I can see quibbling over what “natural” means here, but I would likely unpack it as meaning, roughly, that the reaction is common among humans in typical scenarios involving typical unfairness. And, well, either wanting to steal something is a common reaction to such a scenario, or it isn’t… just like stealing is (or isn’t).
It seems all the same concerns arise about whether I should give the answer I consider most likely to be true, or the answer I consider most normative, or something else.
Can you clarify how “Wanting to steal something is a natural human reaction if a person is treated unfairly” is not a factual question? I mean, I suppose I can see quibbling over what “natural” means here, but I would likely unpack it as meaning, roughly, that the reaction is common among humans in typical scenarios involving typical unfairness. And, well, either wanting to steal something is a common reaction to such a scenario, or it isn’t… just like stealing is (or isn’t).
It seems all the same concerns arise about whether I should give the answer I consider most likely to be true, or the answer I consider most normative, or something else.