Yeah, I actually stumbled upon this argument myself this morning. Has anyone written this up beyond this comment as this seems like the most persuasive argument for paying? This suggests that never caring is not a viable position.
I was thinking today about whether there are any intermediate positions, but I don’t think they are viable. Only caring about counterfactuals when you have a prisoner’s dilemma-like situation seems an unprincipled fudge.
Do you think you’ll write a post on it? Because I was thinking of writing a post, but if you were planning on doing this then that would be even better as it would probably get more attention.
Yeah, I actually stumbled upon this argument myself this morning. Has anyone written this up beyond this comment as this seems like the most persuasive argument for paying? This suggests that never caring is not a viable position.
I was thinking today about whether there are any intermediate positions, but I don’t think they are viable. Only caring about counterfactuals when you have a prisoner’s dilemma-like situation seems an unprincipled fudge.
Yeah. I don’t remember seeing this argument before, it just came to my mind today.
Do you think you’ll write a post on it? Because I was thinking of writing a post, but if you were planning on doing this then that would be even better as it would probably get more attention.
No, wasn’t planning. Go ahead and write the post, and maybe link to my comment as independent discovery.
Of course