red75 comments on Compatibilism in action

red75 29 Nov 2010 17:17 UTC
−2 points

There is no uncertainty about which copy is you, you are both.

However there’s no one who can say “I am both copies”.
- Vladimir_Nesov 29 Nov 2010 17:37 UTC
  −1 points
  Parent
  
  However there’s no one who can say “I am both copies”.
  
  I am both copies.
  - red75 29 Nov 2010 17:56 UTC
    0 points
    Parent
    Ok. There’s no one who can truthfully say “I am both copies”.
    
    Let’s ban word truth. There’s no one who can say “I am both copies” and prove it has same sense as in “I am I (this living thing that speaks those words)” (e.g. I can control my body. I can react to external events in a way I’m previously described or agreed to do.)