If there’s going to be a single “hub” where links to rationalist stuff across the web gets posted, it seems like LW itself is a more obvious Schelling point than /r/RationalistDiaspora.
LW isn’t suitable as-is, I think. There’s more friction to submitting a link (you need to create a text post, put the link in there, and current norms dictate that you write a summary), more friction to following one (you need to click to the post, then click the link), and discussion is ordered by submission time and not votes. It’s like browsing /new on a subreddit that only allows self-posts.
It seems like it might be better to reduce that friction than to try to set up a completely different link-hub site somewhere else. LW’s codebase is basically a fork of reddit’s, IIRC; does that mean there could be a “Links” section (parallel to “Main” and “Discussion”, I guess) that behaves more like a typical subreddit?
(I have to say that on Reddit and HN I actually almost always prefer to go first to the local discussion rather than just following the external link—so I’m not so concerned about “more friction to following one [link]”. But that’s dependent on there usually being some local discussion.)
Perhaps. I’m not sure LW is the right place for it, especially while LW still has original content, and a culture that some find offputting.
Technically, Reddit is pretty customizable, in ways that I think would be difficult to migrate to LW. For example, suppose we wanted to implement Alicorn’s suggestion “granting OP some veto power about what sorts of comments and commenters are allowed under their post”.
On reddit, I think we can get a pretty good stab at it. Create some standard discussion norms, with wiki pages describing them. If someone submits a link with title starting [NO NRX], have automoderator assign it a specific piece of flair. Then use subreddit CSS to add some text prominently to the comments page, “discussion of neoreactionary ideas is forbidden in this thread”, linking to the wiki.
A developer could easily get something similar on LW. But I don’t think it would be so easy for a developer to copy the features of reddit which make a developer unnecessary.
If there’s going to be a single “hub” where links to rationalist stuff across the web gets posted, it seems like LW itself is a more obvious Schelling point than /r/RationalistDiaspora.
LW isn’t suitable as-is, I think. There’s more friction to submitting a link (you need to create a text post, put the link in there, and current norms dictate that you write a summary), more friction to following one (you need to click to the post, then click the link), and discussion is ordered by submission time and not votes. It’s like browsing /new on a subreddit that only allows self-posts.
It seems like it might be better to reduce that friction than to try to set up a completely different link-hub site somewhere else. LW’s codebase is basically a fork of reddit’s, IIRC; does that mean there could be a “Links” section (parallel to “Main” and “Discussion”, I guess) that behaves more like a typical subreddit?
(I have to say that on Reddit and HN I actually almost always prefer to go first to the local discussion rather than just following the external link—so I’m not so concerned about “more friction to following one [link]”. But that’s dependent on there usually being some local discussion.)
Perhaps. I’m not sure LW is the right place for it, especially while LW still has original content, and a culture that some find offputting.
Technically, Reddit is pretty customizable, in ways that I think would be difficult to migrate to LW. For example, suppose we wanted to implement Alicorn’s suggestion “granting OP some veto power about what sorts of comments and commenters are allowed under their post”.
On reddit, I think we can get a pretty good stab at it. Create some standard discussion norms, with wiki pages describing them. If someone submits a link with title starting [NO NRX], have automoderator assign it a specific piece of flair. Then use subreddit CSS to add some text prominently to the comments page, “discussion of neoreactionary ideas is forbidden in this thread”, linking to the wiki.
A developer could easily get something similar on LW. But I don’t think it would be so easy for a developer to copy the features of reddit which make a developer unnecessary.