When someone makes several comments that are longer than the post itself, and when the reasoning is demonstrably fallacious
By this criterion, your original post is a gish gallop since it also included demonstrably fallacious statements.
On the other hand, we could take the charitable reading and say “maybe I don’t understand the point they’re trying to make and we should discuss it”.
By this criterion, your original post is a gish gallop since it also included demonstrably fallacious statements.
On the other hand, we could take the charitable reading and say “maybe I don’t understand the point they’re trying to make and we should discuss it”.