I think that you can legitimately worry about both for good reasons.
Fast growth is something to strive for but I think it will require that our best communicators are out there. Are you concerned that rationality teachers without secret lives won’t be inspiring enough to convert people or that they’ll get things wrong and head into death spirals?
From a personal perspective i don’t have that much interest in being a rationality teacher. I want to use rationality as a tool to make the greatest success of my life. But I also find it fascinating and, in an ideal world, would stay in touch with a ‘rational community’ as both a guard against veering off into a solo death spiral and as a subject of intellectual interest. I’m sure that there must be other people like me that are more accomplished and could give inspiring lectures on how rationality helped them in their chosen profession. That would go some way to covering the inspiration angle.
As an aside i appreciate why you care about this; I’m always a bit suspicious of self help gurus who’s only measurable success is in the self help theory they promote. I wonder whether I’m selecting for people who effectively sell advice rather than effectively use advice.
I think that you can legitimately worry about both for good reasons.
Fast growth is something to strive for but I think it will require that our best communicators are out there. Are you concerned that rationality teachers without secret lives won’t be inspiring enough to convert people or that they’ll get things wrong and head into death spirals?
From a personal perspective i don’t have that much interest in being a rationality teacher. I want to use rationality as a tool to make the greatest success of my life. But I also find it fascinating and, in an ideal world, would stay in touch with a ‘rational community’ as both a guard against veering off into a solo death spiral and as a subject of intellectual interest. I’m sure that there must be other people like me that are more accomplished and could give inspiring lectures on how rationality helped them in their chosen profession. That would go some way to covering the inspiration angle.
As an aside i appreciate why you care about this; I’m always a bit suspicious of self help gurus who’s only measurable success is in the self help theory they promote. I wonder whether I’m selecting for people who effectively sell advice rather than effectively use advice.