Yes, that may be true, but that’s doesn’t address the question. A stronger version would be:
Say you have 10 sources who all claim high confidence in proposition A. The arguments produced seem completely bogus or incoherent to you. But perhaps they have strong intuitive or aesthetic reasons to claim A, which you cannot understand. Should you update in favor of A or not?
Yes, that may be true, but that’s doesn’t address the question. A stronger version would be: